Penguin Press
Review by Brian Tanguay

Why have so many people in positions of power and authority capitulated to Donald Trump rather than stand up for democratic principles, the rule of law or basic decency? Profiles In Cowardice by veteran political writer Jacob Weisberg attempts to answer this important question. Deliberately structured like Profiles In Courage, the 1956 book by John F. Kennedy, but reversing Kennedy’s frame, Weisberg explores the stories of people he believes made fatefully bad and self-interested choices at a similarly pivotal moment in American history. These people are: Brad Karp, chair of the law firm Paul, Weiss; Stephen A. Schwarzman, founder of the investment firm Blackstone; Jeff Bezos of Amazon; journalist Megyn Kelly; former Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell; former U.S. president George W. Bush; Sian Beilock, president of Dartmouth College; and John Roberts, chief justice of the U.S. Supreme Court.
Weisberg defines public courage as a principled choice made under conditions of pressure. Cowardice is the avoidance of that choice. Avoidance takes a variety of forms: withholding judgment, going along to get along, hiding behind process and procedure, and self-interested financial calculation. Peer pressure, fear of ostracism and institutional caution are additional factors that make standing up when everyone else is standing down inherently risky. An old Japanese saying applies here: the nail that sticks up gets hammered down. “Once a few prominent actors make the seemingly rational choice of safety,” Weisberg writes, “everyone else can say they’re merely being prudent.” But such prudence can play into the hands of an authoritarian. Authoritarians count on voluntary compliance and preemptive self-censorship. Every individual Weisberg profiles has justifications for their actions, whether Jeff Bezos exchanging the editorial integrity of The Washington Post to fulfill his dream of building space colonies, or Mitch McConnell placing his long cherished goal of conservative judicial dominance above his responsibility to his constituents.
One can argue with Weisberg’s choice of subjects. Why Megyn Kelly and not the top brass at ABC and CBS who surrendered to Trump’s naked extortion? What about the morally dubious capitulation of Christian evangelicals who went all in for Trump? In Weisberg’s defense, the roster of leaders and institutions that have bent the knee is depressingly long; his subjects adequately represent the breakdown of civic leadership and the erosion of professional principles during the Trump era.
While the profiles are generally illuminating, I spent more time on the final chapter in which Weisberg offers a handful of recommendations for restoring moral courage. One idea is for all of us to identify our red lines before pressure to comply materializes. Another is to make resistance and truth-telling a habit, even in relatively inconsequential matters. A third is to bring back shame as a means of enforcing social norms. Like his mentor Roy Cohn, Donald Trump has made himself impervious to shame, and more than any other this trait forms the foundation of his political success; personal scandals, blatant ethical violations and moral turpitude that would torpedo the careers of others bounce harmlessly from Trump. Admittedly, it’s very difficult to shame someone who doesn’t practice similar values, but that doesn’t mean the effort to do so is worthless.
Weisberg argues for a period of civic renewal and a change in our moral weather, a worthy aspiration though one that requires courage on the part of leaders and institutions — political, business and civil society. Courage isn’t the opposite of fear; anyone who takes a stand for what they believe is right and just feels fear. Weisberg concludes that courage is fear disciplined by principle. In a moment of authoritarian siege, courage might be our most reliable deterrent. My sense is that Weisberg has tapped a vein that historians and political scientists will investigate for decades to come. The question of why powerful, wealthy and influential people went along will likely be the subject of many more books.
